← The work-energy theorem and the conservation law

Is mechanical energy conserved here?

An air-hockey puck glides across its table on a cushion of air. A packing box slides across a carpet.

Both move along a flat surface. One of them keeps its mechanical energy. The other loses it fast.

Every conservation solve opens with one gatekeeper question: is mechanical energy approximately conserved here?

Well, the check is a scan of the scenario for three things: friction, air resistance, and collisions.

The air-hockey puck: the air cushion holds it clear of the surface beneath, so friction is negligible; at its gentle speed, air resistance barely acts; nothing hits anything. Conserved.

Is mechanical energy approximately conserved?air-hockey tablepuckfriction: negligible (air cushion)air resistance: negligible (gentle pace)collision: none
The air-hockey puck: no spoiler matters. Conserved: yes.

The packing box: the same flat-surface scene with one change. Carpet grips. Friction is large. Not conserved.

one feature changed from the puck scene: the surfacecarpetpacking boxfriction: large (carpet grips)air resistance: negligiblecollision: none
The packing box on carpet: one change, friction. Conserved: no.

A pendulum swinging gently, air resistance negligible: no sliding surfaces, nothing collides. Conserved, approximately.

bobfriction: none to nameair resistance: negligible (gentle swing)collision: none
The gentle pendulum: trading stores is not a spoiler. Conserved: yes.

Two bumper cars meet: a collision costs kinetic energy in the moment of impact, so mechanical energy is not conserved through the hit.

the contact moment is the scanned featurebumper carbumper carin contactfriction: negligibleair resistance: negligiblecollision: YES
The bumper cars: a collision costs kinetic energy. Conserved through the hit: no.

The word approximately is honest bookkeeping: small spoilers always exist, and the verdict says they do not matter HERE, for this stretch of motion.

So the verdict is one scan: name a friction, an air resistance, or a collision that matters, and mechanical energy is not conserved. Find none that matter, and it is.
Scan: friction, air resistance, collisionsscenariofriction?air resistance?collision?conserved?air-hockey puck (air cushion)negligiblenegligiblenoneyespacking box on carpetlargenegligiblenonenopendulum swinging gentlynone to namenegligiblenoneyesbumper cars meetingnegligiblenegligibleyesno
The whole scan, one row per scenario: the verdict column answers 'is mechanical energy approximately conserved?'

A marble rolls along a smooth, level glass channel; friction and air resistance are negligible. Is its mechanical energy approximately conserved?

Scan the scenario: friction negligible, air resistance negligible, and the marble hits nothing.

No spoiler matters here.

Yes: the marble's mechanical energy is approximately conserved.

A skydiver falls at a steady speed through the air. Is her mechanical energy approximately conserved?

The steady fall looks calm, but scan it: her GPE falls the whole time while her KE stays fixed, and the scenario is full of air.

Air resistance is large here; it is exactly what holds the speed steady.

No: her mechanical energy is not conserved; air resistance matters.

One cue to carry into the drill: a cushion of air holds a glider clear of the surface beneath it, so sliding friction there is negligible, even while a fan keeps the cushion blowing.

A hovercraft toy skims across a gym floor on its cushion of air at a gentle pace. Is its mechanical energy approximately conserved?

A packing crate slides across rough concrete. Is its mechanical energy approximately conserved?

A pendulum in a science room swings gently, with negligible air resistance. Is its mechanical energy approximately conserved?

An ice skater glides in a straight line across smooth rink ice, friction negligible. Is her mechanical energy approximately conserved?

A skydiver falls at a steady speed through the air. Is her mechanical energy approximately conserved?

Two shopping carts roll into each other and latch together. Is their mechanical energy approximately conserved through the impact?

Your turn

In which scenario is the sled's mechanical energy approximately conserved?

A marble run has four sections. On which section is the marble's mechanical energy NOT approximately conserved?

A hockey puck crosses smooth rink ice, friction negligible, then slides onto a stretch of bare concrete. On which stretch is its mechanical energy approximately conserved?